Baseball Glove Size Guide: What Size Glove for Each Position?

Choosing the Right Baseball Glove Size for Your Position

One of the most common questions we hear at Kinni Sporting Goods is: "What size baseball glove should I buy?" The answer isn't one-size-fits-all - it depends on the position you play, your age, and your skill level.

Using the wrong size glove can hurt your performance, slow your development, and even lead to errors on the field. This comprehensive guide will help you choose the perfect glove size for every position.

Quick Reference: Glove Size by Position

Understanding Glove Measurements

Baseball glove sizes are measured from the top of the index finger, down along the glove, to the center of the heel of the glove. This measurement is typically given in inches.

Important Note:

Glove sizes can vary slightly between manufacturers. A 11.5" glove from one brand might feel different than an 11.5" from another. Always try on gloves when possible, or buy from retailers with good return policies.

Position-by-Position Breakdown

Pitcher's Glove: 11.5" - 12"

Why This Size:

• Large enough to hide grip and pitch selection from base runners
• Closed web design is essential (no H-web or I-web)
• Not too large - pitchers need to field their position
• Quick ball transfer for fielding bunts and comebackers

Key Features to Look For:

• Closed web (basket web or closed pocket)
• Medium pocket depth
• Lightweight for quick movements
• Comfortable fit for long outings

Common Mistakes:

• ❌ Using an open web (reveals grip to runners)
• ❌ Going too large (slows fielding ability)
• ❌ Using an outfield glove (too big, wrong web)

Pro Tip: Many pitchers prefer gloves in the 11.75" range - large enough to hide the ball but not so big that it affects fielding.

Catcher's Mitt: 32.5" - 34"

Why This Size:

• Measured differently (circumference, not length)
• Extra padding to protect hand from fastballs
• Deep pocket to secure pitches
• Closed web for framing pitches

Key Features to Look For:

• Extra padding in palm and pocket
• One-piece solid web
• Reinforced heel for blocking
• Break-in point for easy closing

Youth vs Adult:

• Youth (ages 8-12): 31" - 32.5" - Lighter weight, easier to close
• Teen (ages 13-15): 32" - 33" - Transitional size
• Adult (16+): 32.5" - 34" - Full-size, maximum protection

Common Mistakes:

• ❌ Using a first base mitt (wrong shape, no padding)
• ❌ Going too small (less protection, harder to frame)
• ❌ Not breaking in properly (leads to hand injuries)

First Base Mitt: 12" - 13"

Why This Size:

• Largest glove on the field (except catcher)
• Provides maximum target for infielders
• Scoop design helps dig balls out of dirt
• Single post web for flexibility

Key Features to Look For:

• Elongated shape (not rounded like outfield gloves)
• Deep pocket for securing throws
• Flexible web for scooping
• Lightweight despite large size

Youth vs Adult:

• Youth: 12" - 12.5" - Easier to control
• Adult: 12.5" - 13" - Maximum reach

Common Mistakes:

• ❌ Using a regular infield glove (too small, wrong shape)
• ❌ Going too large for youth players (can't control it)
• ❌ Using an outfield glove (wrong web pattern)

Pro Tip: First base mitts are designed specifically for the position - don't use a regular glove or outfield glove at first base.

Second Base Glove: 11" - 11.5"

Why This Size:

• Smallest infield glove for quickest transfers
• Shallow pocket for fast double plays
• Lightweight for quick hands
• Open web for visibility

Key Features to Look For:

• Shallow pocket depth
• I-web, H-web, or modified trap web
• Lightweight construction
• Narrow finger stalls for better feel

Playing Style Considerations:

• 11" - 11.25": Speed-focused players, quick hands
• 11.25" - 11.5": Balance of speed and range

Common Mistakes:

• ❌ Going too large (slows double play turns)
• ❌ Deep pocket (ball gets stuck during transfers)
• ❌ Using a pitcher's glove (closed web blocks vision)

Pro Tip: Second basemen often prefer the smallest legal glove they can control - speed is everything at this position.

Shortstop Glove: 11.25" - 11.75"

Why This Size:

• Slightly larger than second base for more range
• Medium pocket depth for versatility
• Balanced for both quick plays and deep throws
• Open web for ground ball visibility

Key Features to Look For:

• Medium pocket depth
• I-web, H-web, or two-piece closed web
• Flexible leather for quick break-in
• Comfortable fit for all-day play

Playing Style Considerations:

• 11.25" - 11.5": Quick, athletic shortstops
• 11.5" - 11.75": Taller players with more range

Common Mistakes:

• ❌ Using a second base glove (too small for deep throws)
• ❌ Using an outfield glove (too large, slows transfers)
• ❌ Closed web (limits ground ball visibility)

Pro Tip: Shortstop is the most versatile infield position - your glove should reflect that balance between speed and range.

Third Base Glove: 11.5" - 12"

Why This Size:

• Larger pocket to handle hard-hit balls
• Extra padding for protection
• Deeper pocket than middle infield
• Open or closed web options

Key Features to Look For:

• Deeper pocket than SS/2B gloves
• Reinforced palm padding
• Basket web or modified trap web
• Sturdy construction for durability

Playing Style Considerations:

• 11.5": Quick-handed third basemen
• 11.75" - 12": Players who prioritize range and protection

Common Mistakes:

• ❌ Using a middle infield glove (not enough protection)
• ❌ Shallow pocket (hard hits pop out)
• ❌ Going too large (slows reaction time)

Pro Tip: Third base sees the hardest-hit balls - prioritize a glove with good padding and a secure pocket.

Outfield Glove: 12.5" - 13"

Why This Size:

• Maximum reach for tracking fly balls
• Deep pocket to secure catches
• Longer fingers for extended range
• Larger sweet spot for difficult catches

Key Features to Look For:

• Deep pocket for securing fly balls
• Trap web or H-web design
• Longer finger stalls
• Lightweight despite large size

Position-Specific Sizing:

• Center Field: 12.5" - 12.75" (balance of speed and range)
• Corner Outfield: 12.75" - 13" (maximum range for gaps)

Common Mistakes:

• ❌ Using an infield glove in outfield (not enough range)
• ❌ Going too large for youth players (can't control it)
• ❌ Shallow pocket (fly balls pop out on impact)

Pro Tip: Outfielders should choose the largest glove they can comfortably control - every extra inch of reach matters.

Age-Based Sizing Guidelines

Tee Ball & Coach Pitch (Ages 4-7):

• Size: 9" - 10"
• Focus: Lightweight, easy to close, builds confidence
• Recommendation: All-purpose glove, not position-specific

Youth Baseball (Ages 8-12):

• Infield: 10.5" - 11.5"
• Outfield: 11.5" - 12.5"
• Focus: Position-appropriate sizing, quality construction

Middle School/Junior High (Ages 12-14):

• Infield: 11" - 11.75"
• Outfield: 12" - 12.75"
• Focus: Transitioning to adult sizes, position specialization

High School & Beyond (Ages 14+):

• Infield: 11.25" - 12"
• Outfield: 12.5" - 13"
• Focus: Adult sizing, premium materials, position-specific features

How to Measure Your Hand for Glove Fit

1. Measure from the tip of your index finger to the base of your palm
2. Measure the circumference of your hand at the widest point
3. Try on gloves with these measurements in mind
4. The glove should fit snugly but not be too tight
5. Your fingers should reach near the end of the finger stalls

Proper Fit Checklist:

• ✓ Fingers reach the end of the stalls (within ½ inch)
• ✓ Palm sits comfortably in the pocket
• ✓ You can easily open and close the glove
• ✓ No excessive space in the finger stalls
• ✓ Wrist strap can be tightened for secure fit

Multi-Position Players: What Size to Choose?

If you play multiple positions, here's how to choose:

Infield/Outfield Combo:

• Choose an 11.75" - 12" glove
• Versatile enough for both areas
• Slightly larger than pure infield, smaller than pure outfield

Middle Infield (2B/SS):

• Choose 11.25" - 11.5"
• Works well for both positions
• Prioritize quick transfers

Corner Infield (1B/3B):

• Use position-specific gloves
• First base mitt is too specialized to use at third
• Keep separate gloves for each position

Breaking In Your New Glove

Once you've chosen the right size, proper break-in is crucial:

Break-In Methods:

1. Play catch regularly - Best method, takes 2-4 weeks
2. Glove mallet - Pound the pocket to create shape
3. Glove oil/conditioner - Softens leather (use sparingly)
4. Ball in pocket overnight - Wrap with rubber bands to form pocket

What NOT to Do:

• ❌ Microwave or oven (damages leather)
• ❌ Excessive oil (makes glove heavy and floppy)
• ❌ Running over with car (can break the glove)
• ❌ Soaking in water (ruins leather)

When to Replace Your Glove

Signs it's time for a new glove:

• Leather is cracked or torn
• Laces are broken and can't be replaced
• Pocket has collapsed and won't hold shape
• Palm padding is worn through
• You've outgrown the size
• Switching positions and need different size

Complete Your Baseball Setup

Once you have the right glove, complete your equipment with:

• Batting gloves - Franklin CFX Pro or Infinite Power for superior grip
• Bat accessories - Kraken grip products for maximum bat control
• Baseball bats - BBCOR certified for high school play (save $50 with BASEBALL50)
• Eye black - Reduce glare and complete your look
• Equipment bags - Carry all your gear in style

Expert Tips from Kinni Sporting Goods

For Parents:

• Don't buy a glove "to grow into" - proper fit is crucial for development
• Invest in quality leather - it lasts longer and performs better
• Consider buying two gloves if your child plays multiple positions
• Break in the glove before the season starts

For Players:

• Try on multiple sizes before deciding
• Don't just copy what your favorite pro uses - they have different needs
• Position-specific gloves really do make a difference
• Take care of your glove and it will last for years

For Coaches:

• Help players understand why size matters for their position
• Encourage proper glove care and maintenance
• Consider team orders for consistent quality
• Teach proper break-in techniques

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use an outfield glove in the infield?

Not recommended. Outfield gloves are too large for quick infield plays and will slow your transfers and reaction time.

What if I'm between sizes?

For infielders, go smaller for quicker hands. For outfielders, go larger for more range. When in doubt, try both sizes.

Do I need a different glove for softball?

Yes! Softball gloves are designed for larger balls (12") and have different pocket depths and sizing. This guide is for baseball only.

How long should a quality glove last?

With proper care, a quality leather glove should last 3-5 years of regular play, sometimes longer for adult players who've stopped growing.

Should youth players use position-specific gloves?

Ages 8-10: All-purpose gloves are fine. Ages 11+: Start using position-specific gloves as they specialize.

Ready to Find Your Perfect Glove?

Now that you understand glove sizing by position, you're ready to make an informed decision. Remember:

• ✓ Choose based on your primary position
• ✓ Consider your age and hand size
• ✓ Prioritize proper fit over brand names
• ✓ Invest in quality leather for longevity
• ✓ Break in your glove properly before the season

Need help choosing? Contact our team at Kinni Sporting Goods - we're experts in baseball equipment and happy to provide personalized recommendations based on your position, age, and skill level.

Special Offers:

• Save $50 on baseball bats with code BASEBALL50
• Bundle batting gloves with accessories and save 50% with code FRANKLIN50
• Team orders welcome - contact us for bulk pricing

Get the right glove for your position and elevate your game today!